There has been some debate in anti-phishing circles over what a hosting service provider should do when taking down a phishing site. It boils down to one of three basic actions the victims witness.

• Redirect the hits to the brands legitimate site - This in my opinion is a dangerous thing to do on many levels and any brand requesting this action will feature on a follow-up shortly.
• Remove the site and throw the 404 error - Just stopping the site working and having the browser present a standard error is the standard check-box reaction & minimal effort.
• Use the hit as an opportunity for education - This is by far my favored option (even though I’ll play devils advocate when it’s discussed). Once a victim has fallen for a phish email, help them to help themselves in the future with some easy to understand education.

Education has to be appropriate, I’m not suggesting at “click time” is a good time for presenting the user at the Anti Phishing Phil game for instance. (Phil is great though if you’ve never seen it). “In your face” education at click-time is a topic close to the heart of the APWG, they will present their advice on the topic very soon.

So back to the raison d’être of this blog, a 10 gallon hat tip to AT&T for this great vishing takedown. [Listen to the mp3]*. They’ve raised the bar with this one and deserve some hearty kudos. I can’t think of a better way of dealing with a vishing number. The continuous unavailable tone has no place here since it’s easily confused with mis-dialing ^{(Homer mp3)}. They have replaced the disconnected service with a great education statement and sound advice too if the caller thinks that they were a victim.

^{* The quality is much better on the phone, I used our conference bridge to record the example.}