There are and always will be different views on security information disclosure ethics. Thus I will not argue in one direction or the other. I will instead bring up a case as a “food-for-brain” example.

Would you trust someone that auction for a CD that “will make a hacker of you in only a few hours“?

What if the same guy sells free tools to “steal usernames and passwords” and “Sniff out AOL conversations“. For only 7.99 pounds you can also buy a “Easy virus construction” kit and “Ready Made Virus“.

Would you really believe it’s all “for educational use only on your own pc to test for any flaws in your system“?

Is this in any way educational, or is just another shortcut to help script kiddies to vandalize the internet? Is this really a good idea?